FMT.cpp

/*********************************************************************
 * Software License Agreement (BSD License)
 *
 *  Copyright (c) 2013, Autonomous Systems Laboratory, Stanford University
 *  All rights reserved.
 *
 *  Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without
 *  modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions
 *  are met:
 *
 *   * Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright
 *     notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer.
 *   * Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above
 *     copyright notice, this list of conditions and the following
 *     disclaimer in the documentation and/or other materials provided
 *     with the distribution.
 *   * Neither the name of Stanford University nor the names of its
 *     contributors may be used to endorse or promote products derived
 *     from this software without specific prior written permission.
 *
 *  THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE COPYRIGHT HOLDERS AND CONTRIBUTORS
 *  "AS IS" AND ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT
 *  LIMITED TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS
 *  FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE ARE DISCLAIMED. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE
 *  COPYRIGHT OWNER OR CONTRIBUTORS BE LIABLE FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT,
 *  INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES (INCLUDING,
 *  BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PROCUREMENT OF SUBSTITUTE GOODS OR SERVICES;
 *  LOSS OF USE, DATA, OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS INTERRUPTION) HOWEVER
 *  CAUSED AND ON ANY THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN CONTRACT, STRICT
 *  LIABILITY, OR TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE) ARISING IN
 *  ANY WAY OUT OF THE USE OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE
 *  POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGE.
 *********************************************************************/
 
/* Authors: Ashley Clark (Stanford) and Wolfgang Pointner (AIT) */
/* Co-developers: Brice Rebsamen (Stanford), Tim Wheeler (Stanford)
                  Edward Schmerling (Stanford), and Javier V. Gómez (UC3M - Stanford)*/
/* Algorithm design: Lucas Janson (Stanford) and Marco Pavone (Stanford) */
/* Acknowledgements for insightful comments: Oren Salzman (Tel Aviv University),
 *                                           Joseph Starek (Stanford) */
 
#include <limits>
#include <iostream>
 
#include <boost/math/constants/constants.hpp>
#include <boost/math/distributions/binomial.hpp>
 
#include <ompl/datastructures/BinaryHeap.h>
#include <ompl/tools/config/SelfConfig.h>
#include <ompl/base/objectives/PathLengthOptimizationObjective.h>
#include <ompl/geometric/planners/fmt/FMT.h>
 
ompl::geometric::FMT::FMT(const base::SpaceInformationPtr &si) : base::Planner(si, "FMT")
{
    // An upper bound on the free space volume is the total space volume; the free fraction is estimated in sampleFree
    freeSpaceVolume_ = si_->getStateSpace()->getMeasure();
    lastGoalMotion_ = nullptr;
 
    specs_.approximateSolutions = false;
    specs_.directed = false;
 
    ompl::base::Planner::declareParam<unsigned int>("num_samples", this, &FMT::setNumSamples, &FMT::getNumSamples,
                                                    "10:10:1000000");
    ompl::base::Planner::declareParam<double>("radius_multiplier", this, &FMT::setRadiusMultiplier,
                                              &FMT::getRadiusMultiplier, "0.1:0.05:50.");
    ompl::base::Planner::declareParam<bool>("use_k_nearest", this, &FMT::setNearestK, &FMT::getNearestK, "0,1");
    ompl::base::Planner::declareParam<bool>("cache_cc", this, &FMT::setCacheCC, &FMT::getCacheCC, "0,1");
    ompl::base::Planner::declareParam<bool>("heuristics", this, &FMT::setHeuristics, &FMT::getHeuristics, "0,1");
    ompl::base::Planner::declareParam<bool>("extended_fmt", this, &FMT::setExtendedFMT, &FMT::getExtendedFMT, "0,1");
}
 
ompl::geometric::FMT::~FMT()
{
    freeMemory();
}
 
void ompl::geometric::FMT::setup()
{
    if (pdef_)
    {
        /* Setup the optimization objective. If no optimization objective was
        specified, then default to optimizing path length as computed by the
        distance() function in the state space */
        if (pdef_->hasOptimizationObjective())
            opt_ = pdef_->getOptimizationObjective();
        else
        {
            OMPL_INFORM("%s: No optimization objective specified. Defaulting to optimizing path length.",
                        getName().c_str());
            opt_ = std::make_shared<base::PathLengthOptimizationObjective>(si_);
            // Store the new objective in the problem def'n
            pdef_->setOptimizationObjective(opt_);
        }
        Open_.getComparisonOperator().opt_ = opt_.get();
        Open_.getComparisonOperator().heuristics_ = heuristics_;
 
        if (!nn_)
            nn_.reset(tools::SelfConfig::getDefaultNearestNeighbors<Motion *>(this));
        nn_->setDistanceFunction([this](const Motion *a, const Motion *b) { return distanceFunction(a, b); });
 
        if (nearestK_ && !nn_->reportsSortedResults())
        {
            OMPL_WARN("%s: NearestNeighbors datastructure does not return sorted solutions. Nearest K strategy "
                      "disabled.",
                      getName().c_str());
            nearestK_ = false;
        }
    }
    else
    {
        OMPL_INFORM("%s: problem definition is not set, deferring setup completion...", getName().c_str());
        setup_ = false;
    }
}
 
void ompl::geometric::FMT::freeMemory()
{
    if (nn_)
    {
        std::vector<Motion *> motions;
        motions.reserve(nn_->size());
        nn_->list(motions);
        for (auto &motion : motions)
        {
            si_->freeState(motion->getState());
            delete motion;
        }
    }
}
 
void ompl::geometric::FMT::clear()
{
    Planner::clear();
    lastGoalMotion_ = nullptr;
    sampler_.reset();
    freeMemory();
    if (nn_)
        nn_->clear();
    Open_.clear();
    neighborhoods_.clear();
 
    collisionChecks_ = 0;
}
 
void ompl::geometric::FMT::getPlannerData(base::PlannerData &data) const
{
    Planner::getPlannerData(data);
    std::vector<Motion *> motions;
    nn_->list(motions);
 
    if (lastGoalMotion_ != nullptr)
        data.addGoalVertex(base::PlannerDataVertex(lastGoalMotion_->getState()));
 
    unsigned int size = motions.size();
    for (unsigned int i = 0; i < size; ++i)
    {
        if (motions[i]->getParent() == nullptr)
            data.addStartVertex(base::PlannerDataVertex(motions[i]->getState()));
        else
            data.addEdge(base::PlannerDataVertex(motions[i]->getParent()->getState()),
                         base::PlannerDataVertex(motions[i]->getState()));
    }
}
 
void ompl::geometric::FMT::saveNeighborhood(Motion *m)
{
    // Check to see if neighborhood has not been saved yet
    if (neighborhoods_.find(m) == neighborhoods_.end())
    {
        std::vector<Motion *> nbh;
        if (nearestK_)
            nn_->nearestK(m, NNk_, nbh);
        else
            nn_->nearestR(m, NNr_, nbh);
        if (!nbh.empty())
        {
            // Save the neighborhood but skip the first element, since it will be motion m
            neighborhoods_[m] = std::vector<Motion *>(nbh.size() - 1, nullptr);
            std::copy(nbh.begin() + 1, nbh.end(), neighborhoods_[m].begin());
        }
        else
        {
            // Save an empty neighborhood
            neighborhoods_[m] = std::vector<Motion *>(0);
        }
    }  // If neighborhood hadn't been saved yet
}
 
// Calculate the unit ball volume for a given dimension
double ompl::geometric::FMT::calculateUnitBallVolume(const unsigned int dimension) const
{
    if (dimension == 0)
        return 1.0;
    if (dimension == 1)
        return 2.0;
    return 2.0 * boost::math::constants::pi<double>() / dimension * calculateUnitBallVolume(dimension - 2);
}
 
double ompl::geometric::FMT::calculateRadius(const unsigned int dimension, const unsigned int n) const
{
    double a = 1.0 / (double)dimension;
    double unitBallVolume = calculateUnitBallVolume(dimension);
 
    return radiusMultiplier_ * 2.0 * std::pow(a, a) * std::pow(freeSpaceVolume_ / unitBallVolume, a) *
           std::pow(log((double)n) / (double)n, a);
}
 
void ompl::geometric::FMT::sampleFree(const base::PlannerTerminationCondition &ptc)
{
    unsigned int nodeCount = 0;
    unsigned int sampleAttempts = 0;
    auto *motion = new Motion(si_);
 
    // Sample numSamples_ number of nodes from the free configuration space
    while (nodeCount < numSamples_ && !ptc)
    {
        sampler_->sampleUniform(motion->getState());
        sampleAttempts++;
 
        bool collision_free = si_->isValid(motion->getState());
 
        if (collision_free)
        {
            nodeCount++;
            nn_->add(motion);
            motion = new Motion(si_);
        }  // If collision free
    }  // While nodeCount < numSamples
    si_->freeState(motion->getState());
    delete motion;
 
    // 95% confidence limit for an upper bound for the true free space volume
    freeSpaceVolume_ = boost::math::binomial_distribution<>::find_upper_bound_on_p(sampleAttempts, nodeCount, 0.05) *
                       si_->getStateSpace()->getMeasure();
}
 
void ompl::geometric::FMT::assureGoalIsSampled(const ompl::base::GoalSampleableRegion *goal)
{
    // Ensure that there is at least one node near each goal
    while (const base::State *goalState = pis_.nextGoal())
    {
        auto *gMotion = new Motion(si_);
        si_->copyState(gMotion->getState(), goalState);
 
        std::vector<Motion *> nearGoal;
        nn_->nearestR(gMotion, goal->getThreshold(), nearGoal);
 
        // If there is no node in the goal region, insert one
        if (nearGoal.empty())
        {
            OMPL_DEBUG("No state inside goal region");
            if (si_->getStateValidityChecker()->isValid(gMotion->getState()))
            {
                nn_->add(gMotion);
                goalState_ = gMotion->getState();
            }
            else
            {
                si_->freeState(gMotion->getState());
                delete gMotion;
            }
        }
        else  // There is already a sample in the goal region
        {
            goalState_ = nearGoal[0]->getState();
            si_->freeState(gMotion->getState());
            delete gMotion;
        }
    }  // For each goal
}
 
ompl::base::PlannerStatus ompl::geometric::FMT::solve(const base::PlannerTerminationCondition &ptc)
{
    if (lastGoalMotion_ != nullptr)
    {
        OMPL_INFORM("solve() called before clear(); returning previous solution");
        traceSolutionPathThroughTree(lastGoalMotion_);
        OMPL_DEBUG("Final path cost: %f", lastGoalMotion_->getCost().value());
        return base::PlannerStatus(true, false);
    }
    if (!Open_.empty())
    {
        OMPL_INFORM("solve() called before clear(); no previous solution so starting afresh");
        clear();
    }
 
    checkValidity();
    auto *goal = dynamic_cast<base::GoalSampleableRegion *>(pdef_->getGoal().get());
    Motion *initMotion = nullptr;
 
    if (goal == nullptr)
    {
        OMPL_ERROR("%s: Unknown type of goal", getName().c_str());
        return base::PlannerStatus::UNRECOGNIZED_GOAL_TYPE;
    }
 
    if (!goal->couldSample())
    {
        OMPL_ERROR("%s: Insufficient states in sampleable goal region", getName().c_str());
        return base::PlannerStatus::INVALID_GOAL;
    }
 
    // Add start states to V (nn_) and Open
    while (const base::State *st = pis_.nextStart())
    {
        initMotion = new Motion(si_);
        si_->copyState(initMotion->getState(), st);
        Open_.insert(initMotion);
        initMotion->setSetType(Motion::SET_OPEN);
        initMotion->setCost(opt_->initialCost(initMotion->getState()));
        nn_->add(initMotion);  // V <-- {x_init}
    }
 
    if (initMotion == nullptr)
    {
        OMPL_ERROR("Start state undefined");
        return base::PlannerStatus::INVALID_START;
    }
 
    // Sample N free states in the configuration space
    if (!sampler_)
        sampler_ = si_->allocStateSampler();
    sampleFree(ptc);
    assureGoalIsSampled(goal);
    OMPL_INFORM("%s: Starting planning with %u states already in datastructure", getName().c_str(), nn_->size());
 
    // Calculate the nearest neighbor search radius
    if (nearestK_)
    {
        NNk_ = std::ceil(std::pow(2.0 * radiusMultiplier_, (double)si_->getStateDimension()) *
                         (boost::math::constants::e<double>() / (double)si_->getStateDimension()) *
                         log((double)nn_->size()));
        OMPL_DEBUG("Using nearest-neighbors k of %d", NNk_);
    }
    else
    {
        NNr_ = calculateRadius(si_->getStateDimension(), nn_->size());
        OMPL_DEBUG("Using radius of %f", NNr_);
    }
 
    // Execute the planner, and return early if the planner returns a failure
    bool plannerSuccess = false;
    bool successfulExpansion = false;
    Motion *z = initMotion;  // z <-- xinit
    saveNeighborhood(z);
 
    while (!ptc)
    {
        if ((plannerSuccess = goal->isSatisfied(z->getState())))
            break;
 
        successfulExpansion = expandTreeFromNode(&z);
 
        if (!extendedFMT_ && !successfulExpansion)
            break;
        if (extendedFMT_ && !successfulExpansion)
        {
            // Apply RRT*-like connections: sample and connect samples to tree
            std::vector<Motion *> nbh;
            std::vector<base::Cost> costs;
            std::vector<base::Cost> incCosts;
            std::vector<std::size_t> sortedCostIndices;
 
            // our functor for sorting nearest neighbors
            CostIndexCompare compareFn(costs, *opt_);
 
            auto *m = new Motion(si_);
            while (!ptc && Open_.empty())
            {
                sampler_->sampleUniform(m->getState());
 
                if (!si_->isValid(m->getState()))
                    continue;
 
                if (nearestK_)
                    nn_->nearestK(m, NNk_, nbh);
                else
                    nn_->nearestR(m, NNr_, nbh);
 
                // Get neighbours in the tree.
                std::vector<Motion *> yNear;
                yNear.reserve(nbh.size());
                for (auto &j : nbh)
                {
                    if (j->getSetType() == Motion::SET_CLOSED)
                    {
                        if (nearestK_)
                        {
                            // Only include neighbors that are mutually k-nearest
                            // Relies on NN datastructure returning k-nearest in sorted order
                            const base::Cost connCost = opt_->motionCost(j->getState(), m->getState());
                            const base::Cost worstCost =
                                opt_->motionCost(neighborhoods_[j].back()->getState(), j->getState());
 
                            if (opt_->isCostBetterThan(worstCost, connCost))
                                continue;
                            yNear.push_back(j);
                        }
                        else
                            yNear.push_back(j);
                    }
                }
 
                // Sample again if the new sample does not connect to the tree.
                if (yNear.empty())
                    continue;
 
                // cache for distance computations
                //
                // Our cost caches only increase in size, so they're only
                // resized if they can't fit the current neighborhood
                if (costs.size() < yNear.size())
                {
                    costs.resize(yNear.size());
                    incCosts.resize(yNear.size());
                    sortedCostIndices.resize(yNear.size());
                }
 
                // Finding the nearest neighbor to connect to
                // By default, neighborhood states are sorted by cost, and collision checking
                // is performed in increasing order of cost
                //
                // calculate all costs and distances
                for (std::size_t i = 0; i < yNear.size(); ++i)
                {
                    incCosts[i] = opt_->motionCost(yNear[i]->getState(), m->getState());
                    costs[i] = opt_->combineCosts(yNear[i]->getCost(), incCosts[i]);
                }
 
                // sort the nodes
                //
                // we're using index-value pairs so that we can get at
                // original, unsorted indices
                for (std::size_t i = 0; i < yNear.size(); ++i)
                    sortedCostIndices[i] = i;
                std::sort(sortedCostIndices.begin(), sortedCostIndices.begin() + yNear.size(), compareFn);
 
                // collision check until a valid motion is found
                for (std::vector<std::size_t>::const_iterator i = sortedCostIndices.begin();
                     i != sortedCostIndices.begin() + yNear.size(); ++i)
                {
                    if (si_->checkMotion(yNear[*i]->getState(), m->getState()))
                    {
                        m->setParent(yNear[*i]);
                        yNear[*i]->getChildren().push_back(m);
                        const base::Cost incCost = opt_->motionCost(yNear[*i]->getState(), m->getState());
                        m->setCost(opt_->combineCosts(yNear[*i]->getCost(), incCost));
                        m->setHeuristicCost(opt_->motionCostHeuristic(m->getState(), goalState_));
                        m->setSetType(Motion::SET_OPEN);
 
                        nn_->add(m);
                        saveNeighborhood(m);
                        updateNeighborhood(m, nbh);
 
                        Open_.insert(m);
                        z = m;
                        break;
                    }
                }
            }  // while (!ptc && Open_.empty())
        }  // else if (extendedFMT_ && !successfulExpansion)
    }  // While not at goal
 
    if (plannerSuccess)
    {
        // Return the path to z, since by definition of planner success, z is in the goal region
        lastGoalMotion_ = z;
        traceSolutionPathThroughTree(lastGoalMotion_);
 
        OMPL_DEBUG("Final path cost: %f", lastGoalMotion_->getCost().value());
 
        return base::PlannerStatus(true, false);
    }  // if plannerSuccess
 
    // Planner terminated without accomplishing goal
    return {false, false};
}
 
void ompl::geometric::FMT::traceSolutionPathThroughTree(Motion *goalMotion)
{
    std::vector<Motion *> mpath;
    Motion *solution = goalMotion;
 
    // Construct the solution path
    while (solution != nullptr)
    {
        mpath.push_back(solution);
        solution = solution->getParent();
    }
 
    // Set the solution path
    auto path(std::make_shared<PathGeometric>(si_));
    int mPathSize = mpath.size();
    for (int i = mPathSize - 1; i >= 0; --i)
        path->append(mpath[i]->getState());
    pdef_->addSolutionPath(path, false, -1.0, getName());
}
 
bool ompl::geometric::FMT::expandTreeFromNode(Motion **z)
{
    // Find all nodes that are near z, and also in set Unvisited
 
    std::vector<Motion *> xNear;
    const std::vector<Motion *> &zNeighborhood = neighborhoods_[*z];
    const unsigned int zNeighborhoodSize = zNeighborhood.size();
    xNear.reserve(zNeighborhoodSize);
 
    for (unsigned int i = 0; i < zNeighborhoodSize; ++i)
    {
        Motion *x = zNeighborhood[i];
        if (x->getSetType() == Motion::SET_UNVISITED)
        {
            saveNeighborhood(x);
            if (nearestK_)
            {
                // Only include neighbors that are mutually k-nearest
                // Relies on NN datastructure returning k-nearest in sorted order
                const base::Cost connCost = opt_->motionCost((*z)->getState(), x->getState());
                const base::Cost worstCost = opt_->motionCost(neighborhoods_[x].back()->getState(), x->getState());
 
                if (opt_->isCostBetterThan(worstCost, connCost))
                    continue;
                xNear.push_back(x);
            }
            else
                xNear.push_back(x);
        }
    }
 
    // For each node near z and in set Unvisited, attempt to connect it to set Open
    std::vector<Motion *> yNear;
    std::vector<Motion *> Open_new;
    const unsigned int xNearSize = xNear.size();
    for (unsigned int i = 0; i < xNearSize; ++i)
    {
        Motion *x = xNear[i];
 
        // Find all nodes that are near x and in set Open
        const std::vector<Motion *> &xNeighborhood = neighborhoods_[x];
 
        const unsigned int xNeighborhoodSize = xNeighborhood.size();
        yNear.reserve(xNeighborhoodSize);
        for (unsigned int j = 0; j < xNeighborhoodSize; ++j)
        {
            if (xNeighborhood[j]->getSetType() == Motion::SET_OPEN)
                yNear.push_back(xNeighborhood[j]);
        }
 
        // Find the lowest cost-to-come connection from Open to x
        base::Cost cMin(opt_->infiniteCost());
        Motion *yMin = getBestParent(x, yNear, cMin);
        yNear.clear();
 
        // If an optimal connection from Open to x was found
        if (yMin != nullptr)
        {
            bool collision_free = false;
            if (cacheCC_)
            {
                if (!yMin->alreadyCC(x))
                {
                    collision_free = si_->checkMotion(yMin->getState(), x->getState());
                    ++collisionChecks_;
                    // Due to FMT* design, it is only necessary to save unsuccesful
                    // connection attemps because of collision
                    if (!collision_free)
                        yMin->addCC(x);
                }
            }
            else
            {
                ++collisionChecks_;
                collision_free = si_->checkMotion(yMin->getState(), x->getState());
            }
 
            if (collision_free)
            {
                // Add edge from yMin to x
                x->setParent(yMin);
                x->setCost(cMin);
                x->setHeuristicCost(opt_->motionCostHeuristic(x->getState(), goalState_));
                yMin->getChildren().push_back(x);
 
                // Add x to Open
                Open_new.push_back(x);
                // Remove x from Unvisited
                x->setSetType(Motion::SET_CLOSED);
            }
        }  // An optimal connection from Open to x was found
    }  // For each node near z and in set Unvisited, try to connect it to set Open
 
    // Update Open
    Open_.pop();
    (*z)->setSetType(Motion::SET_CLOSED);
 
    // Add the nodes in Open_new to Open
    unsigned int openNewSize = Open_new.size();
    for (unsigned int i = 0; i < openNewSize; ++i)
    {
        Open_.insert(Open_new[i]);
        Open_new[i]->setSetType(Motion::SET_OPEN);
    }
    Open_new.clear();
 
    if (Open_.empty())
    {
        if (!extendedFMT_)
            OMPL_INFORM("Open is empty before path was found --> no feasible path exists");
        return false;
    }
 
    // Take the top of Open as the new z
    *z = Open_.top()->data;
 
    return true;
}
 
ompl::geometric::FMT::Motion *ompl::geometric::FMT::getBestParent(Motion *m, std::vector<Motion *> &neighbors,
                                                                  base::Cost &cMin)
{
    Motion *min = nullptr;
    const unsigned int neighborsSize = neighbors.size();
    for (unsigned int j = 0; j < neighborsSize; ++j)
    {
        const base::State *s = neighbors[j]->getState();
        const base::Cost dist = opt_->motionCost(s, m->getState());
        const base::Cost cNew = opt_->combineCosts(neighbors[j]->getCost(), dist);
 
        if (opt_->isCostBetterThan(cNew, cMin))
        {
            min = neighbors[j];
            cMin = cNew;
        }
    }
    return min;
}
 
void ompl::geometric::FMT::updateNeighborhood(Motion *m, const std::vector<Motion *> nbh)
{
    for (auto i : nbh)
    {
        // If CLOSED, the neighborhood already exists. If neighborhood already exists, we have
        // to insert the node in the corresponding place of the neighborhood of the neighbor of m.
        if (i->getSetType() == Motion::SET_CLOSED || neighborhoods_.find(i) != neighborhoods_.end())
        {
            const base::Cost connCost = opt_->motionCost(i->getState(), m->getState());
            const base::Cost worstCost = opt_->motionCost(neighborhoods_[i].back()->getState(), i->getState());
 
            if (opt_->isCostBetterThan(worstCost, connCost))
                continue;
 
            // Insert the neighbor in the vector in the correct order
            std::vector<Motion *> &nbhToUpdate = neighborhoods_[i];
            for (std::size_t j = 0; j < nbhToUpdate.size(); ++j)
            {
                // If connection to the new state is better than the current neighbor tested, insert.
                const base::Cost cost = opt_->motionCost(i->getState(), nbhToUpdate[j]->getState());
                if (opt_->isCostBetterThan(connCost, cost))
                {
                    nbhToUpdate.insert(nbhToUpdate.begin() + j, m);
                    break;
                }
            }
        }
        else
        {
            std::vector<Motion *> nbh2;
            if (nearestK_)
                nn_->nearestK(m, NNk_, nbh2);
            else
                nn_->nearestR(m, NNr_, nbh2);
 
            if (!nbh2.empty())
            {
                // Save the neighborhood but skip the first element, since it will be motion m
                neighborhoods_[i] = std::vector<Motion *>(nbh2.size() - 1, nullptr);
                std::copy(nbh2.begin() + 1, nbh2.end(), neighborhoods_[i].begin());
            }
            else
            {
                // Save an empty neighborhood
                neighborhoods_[i] = std::vector<Motion *>(0);
            }
        }
    }
}